Skip to main content

Article Summary

To understand how directors get pay rises approved, recognise the decision is not made in the meeting with your manager. It is made afterwards by a CFO calculating total reward against replacement cost. In the UK, variable pay matters more than base. In the GCC, end-of-service gratuity compounds every base salary increase retrospectively.

Last updated: May 2026

You ask your manager for a pay rise. They listen, nod, agree the case makes sense. Three weeks later the answer comes back: a 2 per cent adjustment in line with the broader cycle. What happened in the room you were not in is what decided the answer.

Twenty years in senior talent acquisition roles across multiple organisations and sectors, up to global head of TA level, taught me the decision was never going to be your manager’s. The manager is the advocate. The CFO is the decision-maker. The case the manager carries upward is filtered through their words, their priorities, and the compensation envelope they were handed for the cycle. The directors I saw approved at the top of the range had cases that survived the relay upward intact.

This article walks through the room you were not in. Understanding how directors get pay rises approved means understanding three things: where the decision actually gets made, what the CFO is calculating when it gets there, and how the package itself differs between UK and GCC markets in ways that change the lever.

Where Do Director-Level Pay Decisions Actually Get Made?

Director-level pay decisions are made by a CFO or compensation committee, not by the line manager who first hears the request. The manager is the advocate; the CFO is the decision-maker.

This is the first thing most directors get wrong about how directors get pay rises approved. They prepare the case as though the manager will approve it directly. They rehearse the conversation. They walk into the meeting confident the case has landed.

The case is not for the manager. It is for the room the manager will be in three weeks later, alongside their own boss, the HR director, and the CFO. The manager is reciting a version of the original case, filtered through their own words and political calculations. If the case the manager carries upward is the wrong case, the director’s preparation was wasted before the decision was attempted.

What the CFO walks into that conversation with is not your CV. It is a compensation envelope, a replacement cost calculation, and a retention priority matrix ranking you against every other director in the budget cycle.

What Is the CFO Actually Calculating?

The CFO is calculating total reward against replacement cost, not headline salary against your contribution. A 5% base increase is rarely worth 5% to the company; it compounds through pension, bonus accrual, and in the GCC, end-of-service gratuity.

What is total reward? Total reward is the full annual cost of employing you across every component the company funds: base, bonus, LTIPs, pension, healthcare, car allowance, and in the GCC, housing, transport, school fees and end-of-service gratuity. Headline base is typically 40 to 60 per cent of total reward at director and VP level. The rest is where the money sits.

When a director asks for 5% on base, the CFO runs a downstream calculation: 5% on base, plus pension contribution, plus bonus pool entitlement, plus LTIP grant size, all of which scale with base. A 5% base ask is closer to 8 to 10% in real cost.

Replacement cost at director level runs between 25 and 35 per cent of first-year total compensation for a retained executive search, before counting the six to twelve months a replacement needs to reach effectiveness. A £15,000 base rise is cheap against that arithmetic, but only if someone in the room has made the equation visible.

This is the core of how directors get pay rises approved. The CFO is not deciding whether you deserve more. The CFO is deciding whether retaining you is cheaper than replacing you. For the panel-side analysis of how that runs in practice, see my piece on executive salary negotiation.

Why Is Base Salary Often the Wrong Target in UK Negotiations?

In UK director-level pay negotiations, base salary is often the smallest component of the total package and the least flexible to negotiate. The real money sits in variable pay: bonus, LTIPs, and equity, where the CFO has materially more room to approve.

UK director and VP compensation has structurally shifted toward variable pay over the past decade. Among FTSE 100 CEOs in 2024/25, 93 per cent received an annual bonus at a mean of £1.61 million, against base salaries between £800,000 and £1.5 million (High Pay Centre FTSE 100 CEO Pay Review 2025). Target bonus is typically 100 per cent of base, maximum 200 per cent for listed companies. Mid-market and PE-backed packages mirror this at smaller scale: bonus targets of 30 to 60 per cent of base, with LTIPs layered on top.

This changes the negotiation entirely. When a director asks for 5% on base and the CFO declines, the conversation often ends there. But the same CFO will frequently approve a 20% uplift in target bonus, an accelerated LTIP grant, or a deferred share award. These cost less in headline P&L terms and tie retention to performance.

Knowing how directors get pay rises approved in the UK means knowing this trade-off before walking in. The directors who win the longest walk out with a bigger total reward package by accepting that base is the symbolic number; bonus structure is where the movement happens. The one exception: if your base salary is materially below market, fix that first. Base is the multiplier everything else compounds from. Fight on base only if base is wrong; otherwise fight on variable.

How Does GCC End-of-Service Gratuity Change the Calculation?

In the GCC, end-of-service gratuity is a statutory multiplier that compounds every base salary increase retrospectively across accrued years of service. This makes base movement materially more expensive than in the UK and changes what gets approved.


End-of-service gratuity is set in law, not contract. In Saudi Arabia: half a month’s wage per year for the first five years, then one full month per year thereafter, calculated on the last drawn salary including fixed allowances forming part of regular remuneration (Saudi Labour Law Articles 84 to 87). In the UAE: 21 days for each of the first five years, then 30 days per year thereafter, capped at two years’ total wage (Federal Decree-Law 33 of 2021, Article 51). Both apply to basic salary; package structure matters.

The compounding effect is what most directors miss about how directors get pay rises approved in the GCC. A director on SAR 1.2 million base with six years of service has already accrued the equivalent of four months’ gratuity. A 5% base increase does not just raise next year’s salary. It revalues the entire accrued gratuity at the new base. The CFO is approving 5% on next year, plus the retrospective uplift across accrued service, plus a higher accrual rate going forward.

This is why GCC CFOs are typically more cautious on base movement than their UK counterparts and why the negotiation lever in the GCC is often housing, transport, or discretionary bonus rather than base. Housing allowances do not feed gratuity. Bonuses do not feed gratuity. Allowances not classified as part of regular remuneration do not compound.

How directors get pay rises approved in the GCC therefore requires a different conversation. The strongest case increases total reward without increasing the base component that compounds through gratuity. A director who asks for “5% on base” in Riyadh is asking for something materially more expensive than the same director asking for “5% in total compensation, structured through housing and bonus.” See my piece on Saudi executive interview preparation for the broader picture.

Preparing for a Director-Level Pay Conversation?

The package that gets approved is rarely the one most directors prepare. A 15-minute call can reframe the case before the relay begins.

Book Your Free 15-Minute Consultation →

How Can You Reverse-Engineer What the CFO Will Approve?

The most reliable way to get a director-level pay rise approved is to reverse-engineer the conversation from the CFO’s perspective back to your manager. Start with what the CFO will approve, then build the case your manager needs to carry into the room.

What is Reverse Engineering? Reverse Engineering is the approach I use with my clients to structure every career and compensation decision. Rather than starting with what the director wants to ask for, we start with what the decision-makers will approve and build the case backwards from that destination.

Applied to a pay rise, reverse engineering means asking three questions. What does the CFO save by retaining me? Replacement cost: search fees, ramp-up time, relationship risk. What makes the retention decision easier to justify to the compensation committee? Retention priority: institutional knowledge, client relationships, business-critical scarcity. What is the cheapest possible package that retains me? Structure: bonus uplift in the UK, allowance restructure in the GCC, deferred award rather than base.

This is how directors get pay rises approved across both markets. Not by arguing harder. By arguing for a package the decision-makers can say yes to. The directors I see win consistently started preparing six to twelve months before the meeting, positioning the work and visibility so the case was half-made before the conversation began. This is what executive career coaching exists to support.

What Should Your Manager Carry Into the Room?

Your manager needs a one-page summary they can recite verbatim under pressure from a CFO who has not met you. The page is structured around what the CFO will hear, not what you would say.

The format that survives the relay upward is built on the AOI principle: Activity, Outcome, Impact. Three lines maximum, each a defensible commercial argument. Not “I led the restructuring.” But: “I led the restructuring (Activity) that consolidated five entities into three (Outcome), saving £2.4 million annually and removing 18 months of legal exposure (Impact).” The first is a personal claim. The second is a business case the CFO can take to the compensation committee. For the full treatment, see the AOI Method guide.

Give that one-pager to your manager two weeks before the compensation review. Ask: “If you were taking this into the room, what would you change?” Their edits tell you what will not survive the relay. This is the practical mechanic of how directors get pay rises approved: not the conversation with the manager, but the document the manager carries when you are not in the room.

Why the Conversation Is Won Before the Meeting

The directors who consistently win these conversations are not the ones who argue best in the meeting. They built the case for six to twelve months beforehand. The visibility, the documented outcomes, the relationships with people who will speak for them when they are not in the room.

This is what Strategic Career Management exists to do. Pay negotiations are lost in the eighteen months before they happen, not in the conversation itself. How directors get pay rises approved at the top of the range comes down to who has been positioning for the conversation, not who argues hardest when it arrives.

How directors get pay rises approved in 2026 is not about how well you negotiate. It is about how well you have positioned yourself against the package the CFO is willing to approve.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Directors Get Pay Rises Approved in the UK

In UK director-level pay rounds, the decision is made by a CFO or compensation committee calculating total reward against replacement cost. The most common path for how directors get pay rises approved in the UK is a structure that increases variable pay (bonus accelerators, LTIP grants, deferred awards) rather than base, since the CFO has materially more flexibility on those levers than on base salary movement.

How Directors Get Pay Rises Approved in the GCC

In the GCC, base salary increases compound through statutory end-of-service gratuity. Saudi Arabia accrues half a month’s wage per year for the first five years, then a full month thereafter (Saudi Labour Law Articles 84 to 87); the UAE accrues 21 then 30 days, capped at two years’ wage (Federal Decree-Law 33 of 2021, Article 51). The strongest cases for how directors get pay rises approved in the GCC structure the package through housing, transport, or discretionary bonus, none of which feed gratuity.

What Is the Most Common Mistake Directors Make?

The most common mistake in how directors get pay rises approved is preparing the case for the wrong audience. Directors rehearse for the conversation with their manager, but the decision is made later by a CFO who has not heard the original argument. The fix is to give your manager a one-page summary they can recite verbatim, structured around what the CFO will hear.

Ready to Position for Your Next Pay Conversation?

Strategic Career Management is a long-engagement service for directors and VPs who want the next pay round to be a formality, not a fight.

Book Your Free 15-Minute Consultation →

Richard Bunkham

Richard Bunkham FCIPD spent twenty years in senior talent acquisition roles, up to global head of TA level, before founding Total Career Solutions in 2010. He provides executive career coaching for senior professionals through career transitions, job searches, and interview preparation across the UK, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE.